Dentists avoid jail after £46,000 fraud

14:03 09 August 2012

Werner Muller

Werner Muller

Northcliffe Media Ltd.

Two dentists, including one who lives in Norfolk, have avoided jail today after being convicted of a £46,000 NHS fraud.

Two dentists, including one who lives in Norfolk, have avoided jail today after being convicted of a £46,000 NHS fraud.

Dr Werner Muller, 45, of Field Dalling Road, Bale, near Fakenham and Dr John Atkinson, 64, of Finham Road, Kenilworth were found guilty of a double-charging fraud in which they billed the NHS for private work they did at the Clarendon Road dental practice in Hinckley, Leicestershire.

Following a five-week trial at Leicester Crown Court, Muller and Atkinson were both found guilty by a jury of a number of charges of false accounting involving fraudulent claims after they manipulated a computerised billing system.

Sentencing them today, Judge Simon Hammond said he believed it was a “tragic case” involving two men who loved their jobs.

He said: “They clearly were acting dishonestly. What they did was a breach of trust.”

He sentenced them both to 12 months in prison for each offence, to run concurrently, and suspended the sentence for one year.

Both men were also ordered to carry out 300 hours of unpaid work.

Muller was convicted of 20 charges of false accounting relating to 140 fraudulent claims to the health service for work done privately, involving £26,046, during 2006 and 2007.

Atkinson was convicted of 17 counts of false accounting, involving 91 fraudulent claims to the NHS, totalling £20,269.

The General Dental Council is also to carry out its own investigation into the case and Muller and Atkinson could be struck off the dentist’s register for at least five years, the court heard.

Muller has worked at Compass Clinic practices in Wells and High Kelling since 2010.

NHS Norfolk and Waveney said there is no suggestion that he was involved in anything untoward in that time.

The court case follows an investigation from NHS Protect which works to identify and tackle crime across the health service.

Mick Hayes, Anti-Fraud Lead at NHS Protect, said today: “Werner Muller and John Atkinson intentionally misled patients about the NHS treatment they could access, in order to gain financially, and then also billed the NHS for the treatment.

“NHS Protect is working hard to stamp out this kind of fraud, in order to protect both patients and NHS resources.”

Other news

Thu, 14:05
Last year's overall winner.

North Norfolk District Council’s Graham Allen Award has for the last 34 years celebrated best practice in design and conservation in the district and is now open for entries.

Thu, 11:58
Thornham Harbour. Picture: Chris Bishop

Emergency services were called to Thornham last night after a man fell into the water from a boat.

Thu, 09:38

She was injured when a lorry and a moped were involved in a collision this morning.

Thu, 09:27
A Polling Station at St George's Theatre in Great Yarmouth.

Picture: James Bass

Thursday June 23 is the day when the nation will head to the polls to vote in EU referendum. Here is everything you need to know about how to cast your vote.

Most Read

Wednesday, March 11, 2015
9365 - Team of the Year U14  Boys Football

Students, staff and parents at Alderman Peel High School celebrated sporting achievement at a glittering awards night.

Read more
Alderman Peel High School
Thu, 09:38

She was injured when a lorry and a moped were involved in a collision this morning.

Read more
England Ambulance Service
Thu, 06:12
The Berendsen plant, at Fakenham. Picture: Chris Bishop

Noise from a Fakenham laundry has become “intolerable” since it underwent a £2.4m extension, claim neighbours.

Read more
Thu, 09:24
Prince William and the Duchess of Cambridge at tonight's gala dinner in support of East Anglia's Children's Hospices' nook appeal at Houghton Hall. Picture: Stephen Pond/Getty Images

Prince William joked about his wife’s cooking on Wednesday, when he met top chefs before a charity gala.

Read more
A tour around the Kinnerton Factory in Fakenham - On the production line. Picture: Matthew Usher.

Fakenham’s biggest employer has captured a sales uplift despite a “difficult trading environment” thanks to the nation’s taste for chocolate.

Read more

Local Weather



max temp: 19°C

min temp: 12°C


Show Job Lists

Digital Edition

Read the Fakenham and Wells Times e-edition today E-edition

Newsletter Sign Up